By Ben Lerner
It was recently announced that Oscar winners Emma Stone and Jennifer Lawrence will be producing a Miss Piggy film with a script penned by Oh, Mary! Tony winner Cole Escola. For those who can’t wait to see Piggy in action, she’s currently costarring in a Broadway show — but probably not the one you expected.
Miss Piggy and her Muppet friends cameo in Rob Lake Magic, currently playing at the Broadhurst Theatre. The show is what it sounds like: an interactive Vegas-style magic show starring Rob Lake of America’s Got Talent fame. Is the inclusion of the Muppets somewhat random? Definitely. Is it a bad thing? Not at all. If anything, they’re underutilized.
Cole Escola’s script will almost certainly contain raunchy adult humor, but at Rob Lake Magic, the Muppets are as family-friendly as it gets. Lake performs a mix of his famous illusions — not new ones — and includes significant audience participation. There were occasional technological hiccups, but it was clear that magic lovers and child attendees had a ball. And that’s who this production is catered to, rather than a general adult audience or Broadway fans. It’s perfectly enjoyable, if not slightly underwhelming, as a non-magic-obsessed adult, but in many ways it’s a Vegas show on a Broadway stage and operates as such.
Make no mistake: there are plenty of mystifying moments to go around, with several leaving the audience, myself included, dumbfounded. Other tricks employ what seems to be prerecorded video and audio and are less shocking. There are classic illusions like “woman sawed in half” that are not mind-blowing to an adult audience — but again, this is a family show for kids and magic superfans, most of whom seemed to leave amazed.
Even if some illusions run smoother than others, but children under 10 won’t be bothered. Many get to participate, which yields adorable moments. Adults are called to the stage, too, and many of them were no less bewildered. The final trick has a great payoff.
Rob Lake has a good stage presence and grew more comfortable throughout the show, bantering with audience members and leading with self-deprecating humor. These moments land best, compared to the classic Vegas magician moments of bravado. While this is a classic magician trope, the arms-spread-wide pose after the illusion to soak up the glory can come off inauthentic. This is likely because Lake really is a normal, nice, non-egotistical guy with a special talent, though some may come with an expectation of Vegas-level drama. I noticed Lake’s costume — a basic blue sweater on top, leather pants below — almost reflected this interesting mixed persona.
If you love illusions — or have kids who would be excited by them — you’re sure to have a great time full of oohs and ahhs at Rob Lake Magic. If you fit into neither category, it may not be catered to you. It’s playing on Broadway, but it’s certainly more of a “Special Event,” and one that any magic-loving child would adore as a family outing. And while I wish we’d seen more of them, the Muppets are the legendary scene stealers we know and love. As Miss Piggy asks the audience, “It’s good to see moi, isn’t it?” No need to respond — that was rhetorical!
Rob Lake Magic is playing at the Broadhurst Theatre through November 16, 2025. Tickets at www.roblake.com/broadway